What Can I Substitute For Vegetable Oil In Cake Mix

Cake mixes are a convenient way to make a delicious treat in no time. But what if you don’t have vegetable oil on hand? Don’t worry – there are plenty of substitutes that can be used instead! This article will discuss the various options for replacing vegetable oil when baking with cake mix, so you never have to go without your favorite dessert. Read on to learn more about suitable alternatives and how they affect texture, flavor, and other aspects of the finished product.

Substituting Butter Or Margarine

One of the best substitutes for vegetable oil in cake mix is butter or margarine. Butter has a strong flavor, making it ideal to give your cakes a rich and distinctive taste. To make vegan-friendly cakes, use either vegan butter or margarine instead. Tallow butter can also be used as an adequate substitute; however, keep in mind that this type of fat will not provide any extra moisture when baking.

When choosing between margarine and butter as a substitution for vegetable oil in cake mix, both have their own distinct advantages. Margarine gives cakes a softer texture due to its higher water content compared to other fats such as butter. This makes it perfect for creating moist and fluffy cakes with light crumbs. On the other hand, using butter helps create denser textures since the natural sugar contained within it caramelizes during the baking process which adds more body to baked goods.

See also  Does Cake Have Dairy

No matter which one you choose, just remember that they should all be at room temperature before adding them into your cake batter and don’t forget that when substituting different types of fats always adjust the amount according to what kind you are using – usually you’ll need less than what’s called for when replacing vegetable oil with something else because these fats tend to be more concentrated sources of energy!

Replacing With Applesauce

Replacing vegetable oil with applesauce can be a great option for those who want to reduce the fat and calories in their baking. Applesauce is low in fat, full of flavor, and adds moisture to cake mixes. Other alternatives include using olive oil or banana puree as substitutes for vegetable oil in cake mix recipes.

When substituting applesauce for vegetable oil, use half the amount called for; if the recipe calls for one cup of vegetable oil, replace it with a half cup of applesauce. When replacing vegetable oil with olive oil, use an equal amount but keep in mind that olive oil has a strong flavor so you may want to decrease other ingredients such as sugar or salt accordingly. Lastly, when substituting vegetable oil with banana puree, combine ½ cup mashed banana per every 1 cup of vegetable oil called for.

Using these easy swaps offers many benefits including improved texture and taste while reducing saturated fats. By using any of these options instead of vegetable oil your cakes will be healthier without sacrificing on flavour!

Using Coconut Oil

Another great option for vegan baking is to replace vegetable oil with coconut oil. Coconut oil has a high saturated fat content which makes it an ideal replacement due to its ability to hold onto moisture and act as a binding agent. It also adds a subtle sweetness that enhances the flavor of cakes, muffins, or other baked goods. In addition, because this type of oil is solid at room temperature, you will need to melt it before adding it into your recipe.

See also  How Long Do You Bake A Dump Cake

In order to substitute coconut oil in place of vegetable oil in cake mix, use ¾ cup melted coconut oil for each 1 cup of vegetable oil called for in the recipe. This can be done by melting the coconut oil over low heat then measuring out what’s needed directly from the pan or bowl used for melting. However, if you want a lighter texture for your cake mix, try using fruit purees like applesauce or mashed banana instead of all-purpose flour when replacing the vegetable oil. When substituting these alternative ingredients, use ¼ cup plus 2 tablespoons of either one per every 1 cup of vegetable oil required by the recipe.

Overall, there are many different ways to replace traditional oils in recipes such as choosing between vegan options like coconut and various kinds of fruit purees. With careful consideration and experimentation with flavors, everyone can have their desired outcome when baking healthier alternatives without having to compromise on taste.

Employing Greek Yogurt

One of the best vegetarian options to substitute for vegetable oil in cake mix is combining Greek yogurt with canola or olive oil. This combination creates a moist and flavorful result that helps enhance the baked goods. When using this mixture, it’s important to measure equal parts yogurt and oil, as too much oil can make the end product heavy while too little will cause dryness. The combination also provides additional protein which can help with binding ingredients together while giving cakes and other recipes a richer flavor.

It’s important to take into consideration when substituting Greek yogurt for vegetable oil that you may need to adjust your baking time slightly due to its denseness. Also be sure not to overmix your batter once adding the yogurt-oil combination; doing so could lead to an undesirable texture. Additionally, if you’re trying to replicate a recipe exactly then you should note that replacing liquid fats like vegetable oils often requires more than just swapping out one ingredient. Depending on what type of cake mix you are using, you may need to add extra flour or other leavening agents such as baking powder/soda in order for your finished product to rise properly during baking.

See also  Is Mcdonald's Ice Cream Machine Working

When exploring different ways of making vegan cakes or desserts without animal products, experimenting with Greek yogurts combined with various types of oils is definitely worth considering as a viable option. It adds moisture, nutrition and flavor – all beneficial qualities when creating tasty treats!

Trying Avocado Oil

Moving on from Greek yogurt, another popular substitution for vegetable oil in cake mix is to try avocado oil. Avocado oil has many of the same properties as vegetable oil and can add a pleasant flavor to baked goods. It’s also rich in antioxidants and healthy fats, making it an ideal choice if you want your dessert to be healthier than usual. When substituting with avocado oil, simply replace the amount of vegetable oil called for in the recipe with equal parts avocado oil.

Another option is substituting olive oil instead of vegetable oil when baking cakes or any other type of dessert. Olive oil adds a nice flavor that pairs especially well with chocolate cakes or cupcakes. You may need to adjust the amount slightly; generally, use two-thirds the amount of olive oil compared to what the recipe calls for in terms of vegetable oil.

If you don’t have either olive or avocado oils at hand, nut butter could do just fine! Nut butters like almond butter are packed full of nutrients, so they make great substitutes for traditional cooking oils while still adding a delicious taste to any desserts made with them. Just swap out one quarter cup of nut butter per every one cup required by the recipe’s instructions. This makes sure you get all those health benefits without sacrificing too much texture or flavor. All in all, using nut butter as a substitute for vegetable oil can really take your desserts up a notch!

See also  What Are Cake Pops

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Best Substitute For Vegetable Oil In A Cake Mix Recipe?

When looking for the best substitute for vegetable oil in a cake mix recipe, vegan alternatives are definitely worth considering. These can include substitutes such as applesauce, mashed banana or even pureed prunes. However, bear in mind that these options may change the sugar content of your recipe so you should adjust the amount of sweetener accordingly.

How Much Of The Substitute Do I Need To Use?

When substituting for vegetable oil in a cake mix recipe, it is important to take into account the amount of the replacement used. Generally speaking, you can use all-purpose flour or melted butter as replacements and follow a 1:1 ratio – meaning if your recipe calls for 1 cup of vegetable oil, substitute with either 1 cup of all-purpose flour or 1 cup of melted butter. Just remember that when using these substitutes, you will likely need to adjust the baking temperature and time accordingly.

Does The Type Of Cake Mix Matter When Substituting Vegetable Oil?

When substituting vegetable oil for an alternative oil in a cake mix, the type of cake mix can matter. For instance, some cakes require more pourable oils like grapeseed or coconut while others may be better suited to thicker oils such as butter or margarine. Additionally, it’s important to take into account any flavor components that the alternative oil will bring to your cake before making a substitution. Different types of alternative oils have different tastes and textures so you’ll need to consider this when deciding which one is right for your cake mix.

See also  Does Carrot Cake Need To Be Refrigerated

Will The Texture And Flavor Of The Cake Be Affected By The Substitute?

When substituting vegetable oil in a cake mix, the texture and flavor of the cake can be affected depending on what type of fat-free and dairy-free option is used. For instance, replacing the oil with applesauce or nut butter may yield a denser and moister final product than using yogurt or coconut cream as replacements. It’s important to consider how these ingredients will affect both the taste and texture of the cake before you decide which substitute to use.

Does The Type Of Substitute Affect The Cooking Time Of The Cake?

When substituting fats in cake mix, the cooking time can be affected depending on what is used as a replacement. Butter alternatives such as coconut oil or applesauce will require more time to cook than vegetable oils due to the higher melting temperature of those substitutes. Therefore, it is important to keep an eye on the cake when using butter alternatives and adjust the baking time accordingly.


I’ve found that the best substitute for vegetable oil in a cake mix recipe is butter. When using butter as a replacement, you’ll need to use about three-quarters of the amount of vegetable oil called for in your recipe. Depending on the type of cake mix and substitute used, there may be subtle differences in texture and flavor. However, most substitutions won’t affect the cooking time significantly. All in all, it’s easy to find suitable alternatives when you’re out of vegetable oil and still want to enjoy a delicious homemade cake!

See also  How Long Do Cakes Take To Bake